Just take a look at this AP “news story” by Erin Texeira: Republicans’ comments may hurt at polls. Now this is not commentary… it’s what passes for political reporting in 2006.
First, the text rehases the comments by Burns & Allen (not the comedy team, but the Senators) about the “little Guatemalan man” and “macaca.”
But the comments by Burns and Allen have garnered heavy attention as their party is trying to improve its showing among minorities.
These particular statements (and they are a reach) gain such heavy attention because they are reported in heavy rotation (such as repeatedly on the front page of the Washington Post), while others are buried. The story did acknowledge Andrew Young’s recent rant about urban shop owners, but no mention of the host of other Democrats who have made similar statements (re: Hilary Clinton referring to Ghandi as a gas station attendant in St. Louis, Biden making a crack about Indian store clerks, etc.)
It’s one thing to have a dislike for a particular person. Even for something that they said. I can understand that. But other than that, why would anyone asssociate any of these comments, even if you found them offensive, to be indictative of the entire party? And that’s equally true for Democrats as well as Republicans. Rather, isn’t it still in your best interest, regardless of race, to look at the policies of the opposing candidates and vote accordingly? Otherwise, you need to reject Democrats just as equally as Republicans leaving no one to actually vote for!
Anyway, we are also treated to a quote from Michael K. Fauntroy. Don’t know him? Well you can check out his blog at http://www.michaelfauntroy.com/2006/07/_and_you_wonder.html which includes this point: “House Republicans slapped African Americans in the face again and, given the history of this country that required the implementation of the Voting Rights Act in the first place, poured political salt in wounds that haven’t healed. Along with the controversial 2000 and 2004 presidential elections that clearly disenfranchised Black voters and the GOPs standing among African Americans, the GOP proves, yet again, that it just doesn’t get it with regard to Black voters.” I guess he hasn’t formed an opinion on this yet. (Oh by the way, he has a book coming out. Kind of like quoting Pat Buchanan in an article about immigration).
We even get treated to Katrina lore. (Perception is reality, I guess).
But to top it off, we have a quote from Donna Brazile, of all people:
“Republicans are sending mixed messages to people of color, in particular African-Americans and Hispanics. On one hand they would like us to come into the big tent. But once you get in you will see the unwelcome mat remains on the inside.”
Nice - a Democratic strategist throwing out a slogan in a story about Republican Party… nothing like being fair and balanced.
If the AP would like to write a story about minority voting patterns, then that’s fine. If they would like to research exactly why African-American voters overwhelmingly support the Democratic Party, then fine.
But this ’story’ seems amaturish even for a DNC Press Release.